Wednesday, June 27, 2012

MAT 402: Blog Reflection #1


My adoration for books began at a young age.  I can remember my mother reading me infamous children books such as “The Giving Tree” or “Love You Forever” as a young child.  I soon began to memorize the words (I still called it reading) and would rummage through the pages reciting the words out loud.  I have always been an avid reader.  My enthusiasm about reading can often be motivated and overwhelming.  During the summer of my sophomore year in college, I read a novel entitled “A Thousand Splendid Suns.”  The novel details a story of two women living in the Middle East and their struggle to escape lives of oppression and violence.  The novel was interesting and captivating, but it did not have a profound affect on me.  In the months prior to entering the program I re-read the novel.  The second time around the characters were real and heart-breaking.  It was then that I realized that characters, novels are a means of living someone else’s experience.  I believe that my affection for books, rich stories, drive my passion experiences in an English classroom. 

Initially, when reading Ball’s article I was turned off by the rhetoric that was used.  I felt somewhat attacked when she emphasized the idea of being a master of your content.  It was discouraging because, as a first year teacher, I felt like the level of mastery that was being stressed was unattainable as a first year teacher.  As we discussed the article in class, it became more apparent that the emphasis being placed on content was to highlight the idea that an in depth knowledge of your content allows you to captivate the interest of your students.  During the discussion, I became less critical of Ball’s argument because it became apparent that this “mastery” should be something every good teacher strives to acquire as their career unfolds.  Ball highlights the idea that the good teacher, the motivate teacher, will strive to delve deeper into their content and seek to uncover new territory which they can then bring into the classroom.  I agree with Ball on that front.  Teachers should constantly seek to refine and redefine their craft, but it is the passion within the teacher that drives the quest to obtain more knowledge.  Although it may place another task upon the shoulders of the teacher, it is important that teachers have a passion for their content and that passion should drive them to continue to uncover as much as possible about their subject.

At this point, I have no focus for my capstone project.  I am playing with two ideas- but as I continue to focus on them, I am not sure how fond I am of either idea.  The first question focuses specifically on ELD students.  My interest is in what programs can be placed in schools to heighten the chances for ELD students to attend four year colleges? Also, why many low performing students tend to drop out of community colleges. The second surrounds the idea of the “great books.”  What is taken into consideration when deeming a novel a “great book.”  Are the “great books” an essential aspect of content and delivering skills in the classroom? Could more current novels heighten student’s interests in reading? I either need to work to drastically reform one of the above ideas or refocus on another topic because I am not happy with either of these as of now.  At this point, I think it would be wise to do more research on both topics to see if the research could lead me to a more concrete topic and question.

See my Comments for Colleagues:
Alana Scott: mademoisellescott.blogspot.com
Mike Rose: Mikejas.blogspot.com
Sheridan Arrendondo: sheridanarredondo.blogspot.com
 

6 comments:

  1. Courtney-

    I just realized that I responded to you blog, but failed to type in the little "prove your not a robot" thing so it didn't publish. FAIL. First, your picture is amazing. You look awesome! Anyways, I find it interesting that in reading others blogs, most English teachers have mentioned there love and enthusiasm for reading. I think having a strong passion to read at an early age, has a powerful effect on people. I admire that as I don't like to read because I can't sit and just focus on a book. Awesome.

    I agree with you and feeling somewhat attacked with Ball's article. I was upset because my undergrad study is something totally different that what I teach, so it was annoying to read about content knowledge and mastery. At the end of our discussion, I felt less attacked and I think she just wanted to get the point across that outside learning is important for all teachers to be up to date and balanced.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Courtney,
    Your blog resonated with me for two reasons. The first was that it is funny that you brought up the “The Giving Tree.” This past Christmas I was shopping for my nieces and nephew’s presents and (being the uncle that gives books) I went for the Doctor Seuss, a little “Lorax”, a little “Butter Battle book” and what’s that over there…”The Giving Tree.” I hadn’t read it since I was a little kid but I immediately remembered a forgotten love. I bought it with little more than a cursory skim and brought it home. As I was wrapping up the books lightly skipping down memory lane, I decided to revisit TGT. Ten minutes later, tears dribbling down my cheeks, I realized the power of books. The way the tree (a parent) gives so unselfishly to the boy and he in turn takes and takes and takes opened an image of the sacrifice that family makes to give us (their children) the best was terrible in its power. The second was your connection to the characters in “A Thousand Splendid Suns.” I haven’t read it but I do teach “The Kite Runner” and it was the character of Amir that made that book only the second book I’ve ever read that I wanted to put down. His cowardice and unconscionable treatment of Hassan were hard to read and made for difficult introspection. I love a good book that shows us characters, whether through hyperbole or subtly, demonstrating elements I admire or revile allowing a mirror (if only minor) for our own lives. I believe that is why I stick with the genres I do because it allows for escapism and peter-pan syndrome to flourish, if only for a bit, in my own life.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Court- my reaction to Ball was a little bit different because I was instantly reminded of teachers and colleagues I have known who are complete masters in their subject area but are terrible teachers. They can lecture for hours and even be engaging on occasion just because of their wealth of knowledge. But teaching is SO much more than that- and I believe a over-dependence on your content area knowledge can, in fact, encourage some really lazy teaching that has nothing to do with what the students actually need to learn.

    As far as your project goes, I wonder if you could combine the idea of "good books" and your interest in ELD- are there specific books that can spark motivation and engage ELD students in language studies? You could even pilot a new novel as your project- I can give you the district guidelines for that process (for example- "Diary of a Part-Time Indian" that we did with Juniors). Something to think about!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am also a a teacher that is going to focus my capstone project with an emphasis on English, only I will be focusing on writing. I agree with our other fellow students that teaching Literature must begin with a love for reading. I too love the giving tree, and it holds a special place in my heart when thinking of the GREAT BOOKS, that I read as a child.

    Much like you when I first read the Ball article I felt somewhat attacked when she was saying that teachers need to have their content knowledge mastered especially as an elementary school teacher, because that would mean I would need to be a master in all subjects. Which in my opinion is unrealistic. I felt like after the discussion in my class at least, I felt somewhat less attacked as a teacher because like you said any good teacher would be putting in the effort to keep learning the content of any subject they teach. Yet I am still left with the question of how a teacher can go about possessing this knowledge without spending multiple years in college courses.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Courtney,

    I was struck by your love of reading, and it occurred to me that you might want to explore how to teach a novel to ELD students (you'd have to choose a grade level). Often ELD students are often offered small passages of reading rather than a novel. Perhaps you could look at strategies for teaching a novel, which would inspire a love of reading along with literacy.

    Thanks for the annotations.

    Molly

    ReplyDelete
  6. Courtney Lyon,

    I really like your second idea for the focus question. I think a lot of us may be trying to create questions that are really complicated because they’re driven by things we see in the profession that confuse us, or aspects of our work that we find challenging and are wondering how to figure out. However, I think when it comes to the research that is going to be required of us, I think your second question could lead to more interesting discoveries, more research, and overall more to say. I could be completely wrong, but I’m thinking that if you’re looking at specific pieces of literature and what makes those books the “great books” then you will for one, absolutely have primary sources, and secondly, I think it could lead you to more fun experiential recourses. I don’t know what it would be like to track down authors or scholars on authors of the “great books”, but I think there could be some potential there. Especially if your question goes more in the direction of teaching more current literature, there are so many literary events in the city and around the bay area that could totally shed light on the value and relevance that more current literature could provide. I hope that helps a little! ☺

    ReplyDelete